Maybelline Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner ($7.94) I was so delighted to have found this gel liner. It is waterproof and works well on the waterline. I nabbed the eyeliner in all 4 colors: black, brown, grey, and plum. They all are pigmented and go on creamy smooth. The color lasts all day and doesn’t budge until you remove it. I think it is the perfect replacement for MAC Fluidline. It’s almost half the price (even cheaper during sales!) and comes with a brush! I think this the best drugstore eyeliner and probably one of the best eyeliners on the market. I just wish it came with a tiny bit more product. It’s about the same size as MAC’s Fluidline.